Pin it
This indulgent Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie blends velvety peanut butter filling with light whipped topping and crunchy peanut butter bits for a treat that's both comforting and extraordinary. The interplay between smooth filling and textured crumbles makes an unforgettable dessert that's become a fixture at our family celebrations.
I whipped up this pie for the first time when my mother-in-law visited, knowing she's crazy about anything peanut buttery. Seeing her reaction after the first taste told me right away we'd be making this again and again. Now we can't have a holiday dinner without it.
Ingredients
- Prebaked 9-inch pie crust: Forms the base for this silky dessert. Grab one from the store if you're in a hurry - it'll work just as well.
- Powdered sugar: Gives the right amount of sweetness and helps create those perfect crumbles. It mixes in without any graininess.
- Creamy peanut butter: The star of our show. Go with brands like Skippy or Jif for the smoothest results and best taste.
- Instant vanilla pudding mix: Makes sure your filling firms up properly. The vanilla taste really brings out the peanut butter flavor.
- Milk: Gets the pudding going. Full-fat milk makes it creamier, but 2% does the job too.
- Whipped cream or Cool Whip: Adds fluffiness to both filling and topping. Freshly whipped tastes amazing but the tub stuff saves time.
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Make Your Crumbles:
- Mix together peanut butter and powdered sugar in a bowl with a fork until you get little pea-sized bits. They should stick when pressed but crumble easily too. Save half for decorating later.
- Prepare The Filling:
- Beat the vanilla pudding mix, milk, and peanut butter together for 2 full minutes until completely smooth. The mix will get pretty thick as you stir. Don't forget to scrape down the sides so everything gets mixed evenly.
- Fluff Up The Filling:
- Carefully fold in whipped cream with a rubber spatula. Don't stir too hard - use a figure-eight motion, cutting through the middle and folding bottom over top. Keep going until it's all mixed but still airy. Your filling should be fluffy but not runny.
- Build Your Pie:
- Scatter half your peanut butter crumbles across the bottom of the cooled crust. Pour your filling on top and smooth it out. Those hidden crumbles will give a nice surprise in each bite.
- Finish And Chill:
- Spread whipped cream or Cool Whip all over the top, making some nice swirls if you want. Put it in the fridge for at least 2 hours so it can set up. Just before you serve it, sprinkle those remaining crumbles on top for extra crunch and prettiness.
Pin it
What really makes this pie stand out are those special peanut butter crumbles. I learned about them while chatting with an Amish baker at our farmers market. She told me that mixing different textures is what gives traditional Amish desserts their memorable quality. Every single time I bring this pie somewhere, at least one person asks me how to make it.
Choosing The Right Peanut Butter
Regular creamy peanut butter works way better than the natural stuff in this recipe. Natural peanut butter tends to split apart and can make your filling oily. Stick with Jif, Peter Pan, or Skippy for the best results and sweetness. If you want a stronger peanut flavor, try mixing your regular peanut butter with a couple tablespoons of peanut butter powder.
Make It Your Own
The basic recipe tastes amazing, but you can totally switch things up. Try adding thin banana slices between the crumbles and filling for a banana twist. Or drizzle some chocolate sauce on top before sprinkling the final crumbles for a peanut butter cup feel. Want something extra? Mix some mini chocolate chips into the filling or scatter them on top with your crumbles.
Serving Suggestions
This pie goes great with hot coffee or a glass of cold milk. For fancy occasions, serve each piece with a small scoop of chocolate ice cream on the side. The warm-cold contrast between ice cream and pie tastes amazing. Planning a party? Make mini versions in a muffin tin using cookie crusts for cute single-serving treats that everyone will love.
Pin it
This pie makes a no-fuss but wow-worthy dessert that'll make any peanut butter fan smile.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make this with a homemade crust?
Yes, a homemade crust works well for a personal touch. A pre-made crust is just as good if you're short on time.
- → Which peanut butter should I use?
Smooth peanut butter works best since it mixes evenly into the crumbles and filling for a flawless texture.
- → Is it okay to use homemade whipped cream?
Definitely! Freshly whipped cream adds a richer, fresher taste if you want to make it from scratch.
- → How much time should the pie chill?
Let it chill in the fridge for at least 2 hours so the filling has time to firm up. This helps get clean cuts when you slice it.
- → Can I prepare this pie a day ahead?
Sure! Make it a day early and keep it covered in the fridge. This will keep everything fresh and ready to serve.
- → What if I don't have powdered sugar for the crumbles?
You can swap in very fine granulated sugar, but the texture might feel just a little different.