Pin it
I make these peanut butter eggs at home and they blow the store-bought ones away. The inside is super smooth with bold peanut butter flavor all wrapped up in delicious chocolate. My kids go crazy when Easter comes around because they know we'll be in the kitchen shaping these treats together.
Why These Are Worth Your Time
You'll have these tasty peanut butter eggs ready in less than 60 minutes using just six basic items from your pantry. Feel free to try different chocolates or swap in another nut butter to change things up. They're perfect little handmade presents that always bring smiles when tucked into Easter baskets.
Your Shopping List
For what's inside, you'll want smooth peanut butter, unsalted butter, powdered sugar, a pinch of salt and some vanilla. The outside couldn't be simpler - just grab your preferred milk chocolate chips. That's all it takes to make these mouthwatering goodies.
The Making Process
First, warm up your peanut butter with butter in the microwave until soft. Add in your powdered sugar, salt, and vanilla, then mix until it's all velvety smooth. Form egg shapes with the mixture and stick them in the fridge for 30 minutes. Carefully melt those chocolate chips, stirring frequently. Dunk your cold peanut butter eggs completely in chocolate and wait for them to harden. I sometimes add a few extra chocolate lines on top to make them look fancier.
Helpful Tricks
I always wear gloves when forming the eggs so everything stays clean. Don't skip chilling the eggs before the chocolate dip - it makes everything way easier. They'll keep well about 5 days at room temperature, but you can throw them in the freezer if you want to plan ahead.
Custom Touches
Keep your finished peanut butter eggs in the fridge or freezer with parchment paper between each layer so they don't get stuck together. Maybe try some dark or white chocolate for dipping instead, or give almond butter a go for something different from the usual.
Ready to Dig In
These peanut butter eggs look amazing in Easter baskets or served up on a nice plate when company comes over. Grab yourself a hot coffee or tea and enjoy one as your afternoon snack - you've earned it.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Are other nut butters a good substitute for peanut butter?
- Yep, almond or cashew butter work great. Just be aware that texture and sweetness might differ a bit, so tweak the powdered sugar if needed.
- → Why is chilling necessary before adding chocolate?
- It firms up the peanut butter center so it stays solid when dipped. If they soften too much, pop them back in the fridge to harden.
- → How long will these last once made?
- They’re good for up to 5 days in a sealed container at room temp. For longer options, freeze them and thaw before eating.
- → What’s the easiest way to melt chocolate?
- Stick it in the microwave for 30 seconds at a time, stirring after each round. When it’s mostly melted, give it one last stir to keep it smooth and avoid burning.
- → Can natural peanut butter be used instead?
- You can, but it’s thicker and takes more effort to mix. Since it’s less sweet, you might need extra sugar to balance it out.