Pin it
This exquisite Bananas Foster turns basic pantry staples into a mouthwatering treat that feels fancy but couldn't be easier to whip up at home. The gooey, caramelized bananas bathed in buttery rum sauce create magic when they meet cold vanilla ice cream - that perfect contrast between hot and cold is simply unforgettable.
I tried making this treat for my husband's birthday after we fell in love with it at a restaurant in New Orleans. It's now become our go-to celebration dessert that always takes us back to that wonderful night.
Ingredients
- Bananas: Go for ones that are still a bit firm with a touch of green at the tips for the best outcome
- Butter: Pick the unsalted kind so you can manage how salty your sauce turns out
- Dark brown sugar: Gives that rich, molasses-like sweetness that makes your caramel base incredible
- Cinnamon: Brings cozy spice flavor that works beautifully with the sweet caramel
- Dark rum: The classic pick for authentic flavor (you can use lighter types but they won't taste as rich)
- Vanilla extract: Makes everything taste better and more complex (drop it in after the flames die down)
- Chopped pecans: They're not required but add a lovely crunch against the soft bananas
- Vanilla ice cream: The chilly, creamy partner that makes this dessert truly shine (worth buying the good stuff)
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Get your bananas ready:
- Take off the peels and cut the bananas lengthwise into fat strips. You'll want them thick enough to stay together while cooking but still able to soak up that yummy sauce. Put them aside while you make the sauce.
- Make your caramel mixture:
- Put the butter in a big, deep pan over medium heat and let it melt until it starts to bubble slightly. Throw in the brown sugar and cinnamon, and keep stirring until everything melts together into a smooth, bubbling mix. This is the base of your amazing sauce.
- Add your bananas:
- Carefully place banana slices in one layer in the hot caramel. Let them cook about 1-2 minutes per side, gently spooning sauce over them as they start to soften. You want them tender but not mushy.
- Pour in rum and finish up:
- Add the rum around the edges of the pan instead of directly on the bananas. Gently move the pan around to mix it into the sauce. Let everything cook another 1-2 minutes until the sauce gets a bit thicker. Mix in the vanilla and pecans if you're using them, then take it off the heat.
- Light it up (optional):
- For a show-stopping moment, after adding rum, carefully tip the pan away from you toward a gas flame or use a long lighter to set the alcohol on fire. The flames might shoot up several inches but will die down in under a minute. Gently shake the pan until the fire goes out on its own, showing the alcohol has burned off.
- Dig in right away:
- Quickly scoop the warm bananas onto plates and top with cold vanilla ice cream. Pour plenty of the leftover sauce all over. The hot caramel meeting cold ice cream creates the most amazing temperature and texture combo.
Pin it
Dark rum is the game-changer in this dish. I learned this the hard way when I once used light rum instead and the flavor just wasn't the same. The rich, deep taste of dark rum really turns this simple dessert into something truly special.
The Story of Bananas Foster
Bananas Foster came to life in 1951 at Brennan's Restaurant in New Orleans. The chef created it for Richard Foster, a regular customer and friend of the owner. Since New Orleans was a big port for banana shipments, this dish was a perfect way to show off the fruit. The flashy fire technique made everyone want to try it - they loved both the taste and the show. Now it's one of New Orleans' most famous desserts, showing off the city's amazing food culture.
Prep Work You Can Do Earlier
While this treat tastes best right after you make it, you can get some parts ready beforehand for quick assembly. You can make the caramel sauce up to 3 days early and keep it in the fridge. Just warm it up slowly and add the bananas and rum right before serving. Always prep the bananas at the last minute so they don't turn brown and stay perfectly firm. This trick works great for dinner parties when you don't want to spend too much time cooking while guests are there.
Safety First When Flambéing
Setting your dish on fire looks amazing but needs careful handling. Always take the pan off the heat before adding alcohol to avoid unexpected flames. Use a long lighter or match and keep your distance when lighting it. Don't pour alcohol straight from the bottle into a hot pan since flames can travel up into the bottle. Keep a lid nearby to cover flames if needed. The fire will burn out in about 30 seconds, leaving great flavor without the alcohol content.
Pin it
This Bananas Foster will definitely wow your dinner guests and have everyone asking for more!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I choose other bananas?
Absolutely, as long as they’re ripe but firm. Overripe ones might turn too mushy when cooked.
- → What’s a good rum replacement?
Try apple cider, orange juice, or leave it out entirely for a gentler flavor.
- → How do I flambé safely?
Angle the pan away from you and use a long lighter or bring the pan close to the flame. Let the flame die down naturally before serving.
- → Which ice cream flavor matches best?
Classic vanilla is a winner, but butter pecan or cinnamon flavors can also be great options.
- → Can I make this ahead of time?
It’s best fresh, but you can prepare the sauce ahead of time and rewarm it before cooking the bananas.
- → Any nut alternatives for the topping?
Walnuts or almonds will work well if you don’t have pecans.