Pin it
I threw this Broccoli Cheddar Chicken Pot Pie together one dreary, wet night when I needed something truly soul-warming. I mixed my favorite things about broccoli cheddar soup with traditional chicken pot pie and crowned it with cheesy biscuits to make the ultimate comfort dish. You won't believe how the soft cheddar biscuits drink up that rich, creamy mixture below - it's simply divine.
Why This Meal Feels Like A Warm Hug
This goes beyond regular pot pie territory. It's a single-pan miracle that combines all the best comfort food elements. The rich filling with juicy chicken and veggies gets kicked up with loads of sharp cheddar. And instead of fussing with pie dough, these drop biscuits are way simpler but still create a stunning golden top.
Your Shopping List
- For The Topping Magic: - You'll need everyday items like flour, baking powder and soda, a bit of sugar and salt. What makes them special is the sharp cheddar, ice-cold butter and rich buttermilk.
- For The Heartwarming Base: - We'll use quality olive oil with butter, then toss in fresh veggies, herbs and garlic. Some flour, milk and broth make our sauce, then we'll mix in lots of cheese, chicken, broccoli and peas.
Pin it
The Cooking Journey
- Tackling The Biscuits First
- We'll begin with those delicious cheddar biscuits. It's fun to see the cheese work its way through the dry stuff, creating beautiful color spots. The cold buttermilk works its magic when it touches the mixture.
- Creating Our Saucy Center
- This is where the wonderful smells start. Watching those veggies get tender in the oil and butter will make your kitchen smell amazing. There's something special about seeing flour transform into thick, luscious sauce.
- The Final Assembly
- Dropping those biscuits on top is so satisfying. Each one puffs up into its own little golden dome while baking. Don't forget to brush buttermilk on top for that picture-perfect brown finish.
Tricks I've Learned
I've made this so many times and picked up a few tricks. Use a pan that can go from stove to oven to cut down on cleanup. Grab an ice cream scoop for your biscuit batter to make them all the same size. That buttermilk brush isn't just for show - it makes the tops gorgeously golden. Always taste your filling before adding those biscuits, since you can't adjust the seasoning after.
Switch Things Up
You can easily tweak this to match what you like. I sometimes swap in leftover turkey for the chicken or toss in whatever veggies are sitting in my fridge. A tiny bit of cayenne adds nice warmth, and trying different cheeses completely changes the flavor. My kids go crazy when I mix sharp cheddar with some smoked gouda.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can this dish be prepped in advance?
- Feel free to make the filling ahead, but bake with biscuits added fresh. Cold filling might need a bit more oven time.
- → Why toss the cheese with flour for biscuits?
- It keeps the cheese from sticking in clumps and ensures it spreads evenly through the dough.
- → Will frozen broccoli work?
- Absolutely! Fresh gives better texture, but frozen can be added directly from the freezer, just like peas.
- → Why does biscuit size matter?
- Matching biscuit sizes mean they bake evenly. Mismatched ones can be raw or overcooked.
- → What if I’m out of buttermilk?
- Make a quick substitute using a cup of milk and a tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar. Let it sit for 5 minutes.